[Solar-general] Is climate science disinformation a crime against humanity?

[Nicolás Reynolds]

http://ur1.ca/29w93
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/cif-green/2010/nov/01/climate-science-disinformation-crime
Is climate science disinformation a crime against humanity? | Donald Brown |
Environment | guardian.co.uk

Deeply irresponsible corporate-sponsored programmes of disinformation have
potentially harsh effects upon tens of millions of people

  * Donald Brown
  * [48]guardian.co.uk, Monday 1 November 2010 16.47 GMT

[climate change in Bangladesh] Climate change and flooding is already
affecting countries such as Bangladesh. Photograph: Hassan Bipul/DFID

Although there is an important role for scepticism in science, for almost 30
years some corporations have supported a disinformation campaign about
[49]climate change science.

While it may be reasonable to be somewhat sceptical about climate change
models, these untruths are not based upon reasonable scepticism but outright
falsification and distortions of climate change science.

These claims have included assertions that the science of climate change has
been completely "debunked" and that there is no evidence of human causation
of recent observed warming. There are numerous lines of evidence that point
to human causation even if it is not a completely settled matter. Reasonable
scepticism cannot claim that there is no evidence of causation and some
other claims frequently being made by the well-financed climate change
disinformation campaign, and they amount to an utter distortion of a body of
evidence that the world needs to understand to protect itself from huge
potential harms.

On 21 October, 2010, [50]John Broder of the New York Times, reported that
"the fossil fuel industries have for decades waged a concerted campaign to
raise doubts about the science of global warming and to undermine policies
devised to address it".

According the New York Times article, the fossil fuel industry has "created
and lavishly financed institutes to produce anti-global warming studies,
paid for rallies and websites to question the science, and generated scores
of economic analyses that purport to show that policies to reduce emissions
of climate-altering gases will have a devastating effect on jobs and the
overall economy."

Disinformation about the state of climate change science is extraordinarily
– if not criminally – irresponsible, because the consensus scientific view
is based upon strong evidence that climate change:

• Is already being experienced by tens of thousands in the world;

• Will be experienced in the future by millions of people from greenhouse
gas emissions that have already been emitted but not yet felt due to lags in
the climate system; and,

• Will increase dramatically in the future unless greenhouse gas emissions
are dramatically reduced from existing global emissions levels.

Threats from climate change include deaths and danger from droughts, floods,
heat, storm-related damages, rising oceans, heat impacts on agriculture,
loss of animals that are dependent upon for substance purposes, social
disputes caused by diminishing resources, sickness from a variety of
diseases, the inability to rely upon traditional sources of food, the
inability to use property that people depend upon to conduct their life
including houses or sleds in cold places, the destruction of water supplies,
and the inability to live where has lived to sustain life. The very
existence of some small island nations is threatened by climate change.

As long as there is any chance that climate change could create this type of
destruction, even assuming, for the sake of argument, that these dangers are
not yet fully proven, disinformation about the state of climate change
science is extraordinarily morally reprehensible if it leads to non-action
in reducing climate change's threat. In fact, how to deal with uncertainty
in climate change science is an ethical issue, not only a scientific matter,
because the consequences of delay could be so severe and the poorest people
in the world as some of the most vulnerable.

The corporations that have funded the sowing of doubt on this issue are
clearly doing this because they see greenhouse gas emissions reduction
strategies as adversely affecting their financial interests.

This might be understood as a new type of crime against humanity. Scepticism
in science is not bad, but sceptics must play by the rules of science
including publishing their conclusions in peer-reviewed scientific journals
and not make claims that are not substantiated by the peer-reviewed
literature. The need for responsible scepticism is particularly urgent if
misinformation from sceptics could lead to great harm.

We may not have a word for this type of crime yet, but the international
community should find a way of classifying extraordinarily irresponsible
scientific claims that could lead to mass suffering as some type of crime
against humanity.

• [51]Donald Brown is associate professor in environmental ethics, science
and law at Penn State University. The full version of this article was first
[52]published on the Penn State website.


 References:
  48. http://www.guardian.co.uk/
  49. http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/climate-change
  50. http://community.nytimes.com/comments/www.nytimes.com/2010/10/21/us/politics/21climate.html?sort=newest&offset=2
  51. http://www.psiee.psu.edu/psiee_people/faculty_results_detail.asp?faculty_id=461
  52. http://rockblogs.psu.edu/climate/2010/10/a-new-kind-of-vicious-crime-against-humanity-the-fossil-fuel-industrys-disinformation-campaign-on-cl.html

-- 
Salud!
Nicolás Reynolds,
xmpp:fauno en kiwwwi.com.ar
omb:http://identi.ca/fauno
blog:http://selfdandi.com.ar/
gnu/linux user #455044

http://librecultivo.org.ar
http://parabolagnulinux.org
------------ próxima parte ------------
Se ha borrado un mensaje que no está en formato texto plano...
Nombre     : no disponible
Tipo       : application/pgp-signature
Tamaño     : 490 bytes
Descripción: no disponible
Url        : https://lists.ourproject.org/pipermail/solar-general/attachments/20101105/5a073173/attachment.pgp