p2p compared to bricolage approaches! ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Paul Wildman <[email protected]> Date: Fri, Aug 24, 2018 at 12:23 AM Subject: Michel A taxonomy comparing our two approaches fyi this time with taxons and cells fyi ciao paul To: Michel Bauwens <[email protected]> Michel here I seek to illustrate the overlap, synergies and complementarities among/between our two fields/domains and introduce our rationale for the differentiation and discussion point generation table. This table attempts to give a snapshot differentiation (principally overlap) and not adopt *either or* so to speak for differentiation and discussion, *Michel Bauwens comments P2P cp. PB Peer 2 Peer cp. Planetary Bricoleur **P Wildman @19-08-2018 comm. 18-07-2018 250 words over 2pgs* *Table 1:* Comparison of Peer-2-Peer and the Planetary-bricoleur approaches *Meta grounded category* *Fully Human: P2P Haptic/Chiro Capitalism* *Principal Grounded Theory sub-categories* *Issue* *P2P ↔CL - Cosmo-localisation ↔ * *↔ PB - Planetary Bricolage* *[image: cid:[email protected]]* [image: cid:[email protected]] *[1] Value base* *1. * *Re-imagining the local* Re-localisation- networked local production Archaic Renaissance – interfaced intentional communities *2. * *Value base* Networked value matrix Intentional value communities *3. * *Approach to the Commons* Knowledge commons Creative Commons – public domain *[2] Fully Human* *4. * *Expressing our silenced humanity* NA √ *5. * *Skill focus *(H as extension of the tool or vv) Techni Techne *6. * *Homo Haptic** X √ *7. * *Distributed Brain** X √ *8. * *Key interaction* P*2*P (P=Peer) (systems network) *P*Ꞷ*P *(P=Person) (personal interface/netweave) Ꞷ=with; P≡K (Kin) *[3]Cognologic* *9. * *Memetic and Mimetic learning*** X √ *10. * *Ontological anchor* Cogno-mechano √ Chiro-cogno *11. * *Epistemological focus* Abstraction/intellectual Concretisation/handyperson *12. * *Grounded theory *(6 PB category p’les) X √ *13. * *Science* Mainstream Fringe (CRAFTy vignettes) *[4] Economics* *14. * *Informal (non-commercial) economy* √ √√√ *15. * *Economically rational* √√ √ *16. * *GFC2* √ √ *17. * *Economic focus* Transvestment CED – Comm Economy Devt *18. * *UBI* Yes UBC/Contribution with backed local currency in community economy (no State contrib of fiat money) *19. * *Links with capitalism* Formal Network capitalism cp. Netarchial c Informal Community Enterprise capitalism cp. corporate c *20. * *Post-capitalist* √ Networked local economics √ interfaced Intentional comms *21. * *(democratisation of) Rent Extraction* Actively prevented Passively prevented by declining commercialisation *22. * *Local C & Cyber Currency* L&CC LC *23. * *Prosumer* √ √√ *24. * *Aust Tax implications * Within Without hobby *\ *no GST or Tax *[5] Design* *25. * *Resiliency* √ √ *26. * *P2P* √√ √ *27. * *Open Source* √ NA *28. * *Distributed innovation/creativity* √√ √√ *29. * *Ecosystem focus* √ X *[6] Governance* *30. * *Governance* Direct democracy Sociocracy *31. * *Networked -Partnership* √ X *32. * *Pot-latch/Jubilee year* X √√ *33. * *Talk your walk* √ √ *[7] Energy* *34. * *I-Ching (primary energy)* ♂ - yang ♀ - yin *35. * *% of big picture explicated (indic.)* 80% 20% *36. * *Structure* Formal Informal *37. * *Focus* Political-Macro–network-Grand Theory Personal – Micro – netweave – Grounded Theory *38. * *World system* Socio-economic – class struggle Sauvage - Wicca *[8] Theme* *39. * *Theme* Glocal http://www.crafters-connect.com/craft-issue-8/ HHHH– Hand, Head, Heart, Hearth *40. * *Focus* *Interlinking system *→ *maker *Deductive* - systolic* *Individual crafter → CRAFT**** Inductive - *diastolic* *41. * *Moto * Design global - manufacture local Design local manufacture global -- P2P Foundation: http://p2pfoundation.net - http://blog.p2pfoundation.net Connect: http://p2pfoundation.ning.com; Discuss: http://lists.ourproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/p2p-foundation Updates: http://del.icio.us/mbauwens; http://friendfeed.com/mbauwens; http://twitter.com/mbauwens; http://www.facebook.com/mbauwens
