p2p compared to bricolage approaches!


---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Paul Wildman <paul@kalgrove.com>
Date: Fri, Aug 24, 2018 at 12:23 AM
Subject: Michel A taxonomy comparing our two approaches fyi this time with taxons and cells fyi ciao paul
To: Michel Bauwens <michelsub2004@gmail.com>


Michel here I seek to illustrate the overlap, synergies and complementarities among/between our two fields/domains and introduce our rationale for the differentiation and discussion point generation table.  This table attempts to give a snapshot differentiation (principally overlap) and not adopt either or so to speak for differentiation and discussion,

Michel Bauwens comments P2P cp. PB
Peer 2 Peer cp. Planetary Bricoleur
P Wildman @19-08-2018 comm. 18-07-2018 250 words over 2pgs


 

Table 1: Comparison of Peer-2-Peer and the Planetary-bricoleur approaches

 

Meta grounded category

Fully Human: P2P Haptic/Chiro Capitalism

Principal Grounded Theory sub-categories

 

Issue

P2P ↔CL - Cosmo-localisation ↔ 

↔             PB -  Planetary Bricolage

 

 

 

cid:image001.png@01D43B83.12FAFC20

cid:image002.png@01D43B83.12FAFC20

 

[1] Value base

1.        

Re-imagining the local

Re-localisation- networked local production

Archaic Renaissance – interfaced intentional communities

2.        

Value base

Networked value matrix

Intentional value communities

3.        

Approach to the Commons

Knowledge commons

Creative Commons – public domain

 

 

 

 

 

[2] Fully Human

4.        

Expressing our silenced humanity

NA

√

5.        

Skill focus (H as extension of the tool or vv)

Techni

Techne

6.        

Homo Haptic*

X

√

7.        

Distributed Brain*

X

√

8.        

Key interaction

P2P (P=Peer)
(systems network)

PꞶP (P=Person)
(personal interface/netweave) Ꞷ=with; P≡K (Kin)

 

 

 

 

 

[3]Cognologic

9.        

Memetic and Mimetic learning**

X

√

10.     

Ontological anchor

Cogno-mechano

√ Chiro-cogno

11.     

Epistemological focus

Abstraction/intellectual

Concretisation/handyperson

12.     

Grounded theory (6 PB category p’les)

X

√

13.     

Science

Mainstream

Fringe (CRAFTy vignettes)

 

 

 

 

 

[4] Economics

14.     

Informal (non-commercial) economy

√

√√√

15.     

Economically rational

√√

√

16.     

GFC2

√

√

17.     

Economic focus

Transvestment

CED – Comm Economy Devt

18.     

UBI

Yes

UBC/Contribution with backed local currency in community economy (no State contrib of fiat money)

19.     

Links with capitalism

Formal Network capitalism cp. Netarchial c

Informal Community Enterprise capitalism cp. corporate c

20.     

Post-capitalist

√ Networked local economics

√ interfaced Intentional comms

21.     

(democratisation of) Rent Extraction

Actively prevented

Passively prevented by declining commercialisation

22.     

Local C & Cyber Currency

L&CC

LC

23.     

Prosumer

√

√√

24.     

Aust Tax implications                      

Within

Without hobby \ no GST or Tax

 

 

 

 

 

[5] Design

25.     

Resiliency

√

√

26.     

P2P

√√

√

27.     

Open Source

√

NA

28.     

Distributed innovation/creativity

√√

√√

29.     

Ecosystem focus

√

X

 

 

 

 

 

[6] Governance

30.     

Governance

Direct democracy

Sociocracy

31.     

Networked -Partnership

√

X

32.     

Pot-latch/Jubilee year

X

√√

33.     

Talk your walk

√

√

 

 

 

 

 

[7] Energy

34.     

I-Ching (primary energy)

♂ - yang

♀ - yin

35.     

% of big picture explicated (indic.)

80%

20%

36.     

Structure

Formal

Informal

37.     

Focus

Political-Macro–network-Grand Theory

Personal – Micro – netweave – Grounded Theory

38.     

World system

Socio-economic – class struggle

Sauvage - Wicca

 

 

 

 

 

[8] Theme

39.     

Theme

Glocal http://www.crafters-connect.com/craft-issue-8/

HHHH– Hand, Head, Heart, Hearth

40.     

Focus

Interlinking system → maker
Deductive - systolic

Individual crafter → CRAFT***
Inductive - diastolic

41.     

Moto

Design global - manufacture local

Design local manufacture global

 

 

 



--