[kune-devel] Fwd: Finally, kune video-presentation

Tue Jan 20 11:26:24 CET 2009

Y mÃ¡s feedback :) El esperado mail de Bastien. El tÃo es un crack y habrÃa
que tener muy en cuenta sus opiniones (aunque discrepo en varias). De hecho,
junto con Stallman, Ã©l es otra muy buena baza para el proyecto (estÃ¡ muy
metido en el tema, en la FSF y como desarrollador...).

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Bastien Guerry
Date: Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 14:51
Subject: Re: Finally, kune video-presentation
To: Samer

Hi Samer,

as promised, some feedback about the video.

First of all, kudos!  It looks great and contains a lot of information.
I guess many people will want to test Kune after viewing this.  And now
some criticism:

- the musique is a distraction.  Why don't you use the voice, as in any
 screencast?  Yes, it's hard to do, but it's easier to concentrate on.

- What's the purpose?  Advertisement or tutorial?  It's a bit too big
 and to detailed for an ad, but it is "showing off" too much for a
 tutorial.  I suggest you do a 5 minute ad concentrating all the big
 messages (it's enough to make people want to try) and 5 min tutos on
 specific features or use case.

- Would be better if people could have a better idea of the difference
 with other tools.  What's the difference with a wiki?  What's the
 difference with Moodle?  Drupal? Facebook?  Being free software is a
 difference, it might be enough for some devs.  Usability is another
 one, and the video shows it adequately...  but what other deep diff
 with other available tool ?

- The example of Simone: what is the goal of Simone?  What does she
 expect from using this?  Why is she not satisfied with other tools?

- After 4:45, we understand how to create and edit a space, but we don't
 have a precise idea of how this space looks like for people on the web
 (outside the admin interface) (See diapo 8:32)

- The chat feature looks really great.  The video should demonstrate a
 real use case - in what occasion is that really necessary to chat with
 your group?

- Slides at 10:28 and 10:58 contains a bit too much...  or maybe you can
 underline some keywords to ease the reading.

- I wouldn't put kune is not for you...  even technical reasons are a
 bit too much for such a video.  This is good in a faq, but not in a
 video.  (Again, if you answer the question: is this an ad or a tuto,
 you will naturally strip this kind of slide...)

- About the novelty: speak less about them, show them more!  (You could
 actually show *only* this, that would be appalling enough...)

- Slide at 12:03: still in alpha and... "very advanced"?

- "Community supported": how big the community?

- just wondering: is there a "mailing list" feature (which lets you
 contact everyone in your/other group(s) by email?)

Good job dudes!  Tell me when I can buzz around this on mailing lists...

best,

--
 Bastien

-- 
Samer

http://ourproject.org

"No son tiempos para hacer cualquier cosa"
------------ próxima parte ------------
Se ha borrado un adjunto en formato HTML...
URL: /pipermail/kune-devel/attachments/20090120/4fb0fa52/attachment-0001.htm