Re: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production
Well, in my experience I've not heard of any uni enforcing its rights and restricting authors (I'm sure it's happened to someone, somewhere though :P). Sorry Mathieu, I'm, a little unclear on what you meant by 'now it just says "all pubs in public domain"' - what says that? JoPP? On Thu, Aug 17, 2017 at 2:17 PM, Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi Steve, all
We had a lot of discussion about (c) in the beginning and adopted I think CC-BY-SA ? but now it just says "all pubs in public domain".
I guess we need to stay true to our free software roots somehow, so not sure about the uni/author nexus...?
Others?
cheers
Mathieu
------------------------------ *From:* Steve Collins <[email protected]> *Sent:* Thursday, August 17, 2017 12:52 *To:* Mathieu ONeil *Cc:* Journal list; [email protected] *Subject:* Re: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production
Hi Mathieu
What's JoPP's current arrangement with copyrights - is there a current arrangement? I'm guessing that authors don't agree to anything when they submit an article to JoPP. We'll need to implement something for the future - but also need to work on what to do with work that's already been published. To add complexity to the situation it's usual for universities to own the IP in academics' work.
I spoke to a colleague who manages an online journal that is registered with DOAJ, and their (c) statement is quite brief but might provide a template? http://shimajournal.org/index.php Publication Details - Shima: The International Journal of ... <http://shimajournal.org/index.php> shimajournal.org Shima is a SCOPUS registered peer-refereed academic journal that is published twice a year in open access online form and has been registered with the Directory of ...
cheers steve
On Thu, Aug 17, 2017 at 11:46 AM, Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi all, again
To help move things along here are the two places on the journal site where text could be amended. I realise some of you may be enjoying the *dolce far niente* of the Northern summer, but, well...
I've made the required changes to the low-hanging fruit i.e. article processing charges and open access [in bold] below.
However for this next requirement I am less certain; where exactly do we stand on author copyright? Steve and Angela, I'm looking at you! 😊
"Your application also stated that the author does not hold the copyright without restrictions, and does not retain publishing rights without restrictions. However, I could not find any information about the copyright transfer requirement, or an indication of the rights holder for a published paper. This signals a lack of transparency in the authoring and publishing process. If you send me a link where this information can be found, I can update your DOAJ application."
=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=
<http://peerproduction.net/about/mission-statement/>
Mission Statement The Journal of Peer Production (JoPP) seeks high-quality contributions from researchers and practitioners of peer production. We understand peer production as a mode of commons-based and oriented production in which participation is voluntary and predicated on the self-selection of tasks. Notable examples are the collaborative development of Free Software projects and of the Wikipedia online encyclopedia. Through the analysis of the forms, operations, and contradictions of peer producing communities in contemporary capitalist society, the journal aims to open up new perspectives on the implications of peer production for social change. Topics of interest include, but are not limited to: [etc]
CHANGE TO =>
Mission Statement The Journal of Peer Production (JoPP) seeks high-quality contributions from researchers and practitioners of peer production. We understand peer production as a mode of commons-based and oriented production in which participation is voluntary and predicated on the self-selection of tasks. Notable examples are the collaborative development of Free Software projects and of the Wikipedia online encyclopedia. Through the analysis of the forms, operations, and contradictions of peer producing communities in contemporary capitalist society, the journal aims to open up new perspectives on the implications of peer production for social change. *The Journal of Peer Production is an open access academic journal that allows readers to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, and link to the full texts of articles, or use them for any other lawful purpose except where otherwise noted.* Topics of interest include, but are not limited to: [etc]
=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=
<http://peerproduction.net/about/submissions/>
How to submit to the Journal of Peer Production JoPP will be published twice a year. All scientific contributions will be peer reviewed. If you have a question about the suitability of your contribution to JoPP, please contact the editorial team by posting to the (not publicly archived) editorial team mailing list: jopp [dash] editorial [at] lists [dot] ourproject [dot] org Once papers have been accepted, it is the author’s responsibility to format them in accordance with our specifications.
CHANGE TO =>
How to submit to the Journal of Peer Production *No article processing charges (APCs**) or article submission charges are required to publish in JoPP.* JoPP will be published twice a year. All scientific contributions will be peer reviewed. If you have a question about the suitability of your contribution to JoPP, please contact the editorial team by posting to the (not publicly archived) editorial team mailing list: jopp [dash] editorial [at] lists [dot] ourproject [dot] org Once papers have been accepted, it is the author’s responsibility to format them in accordance with our specifications.
=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=
cheers, Mathieu
------------------------------ *From:* JoPP-Public <[email protected]> on behalf of Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]> *Sent:* Thursday, August 17, 2017 8:44 *To:* Journal list *Subject:* [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production
Hi everyone
Response from DOAJ FYI. I guess we need to be more explicit in our language. Does anyone have thoughts on the below?
cheers
Mathieu
------------------------------ *From:* Rhonda Marker <[email protected]> *Sent:* Thursday, August 17, 2017 8:24 *To:* Mathieu ONeil *Cc:* Rhonda Marker *Subject:* Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production
Dear Dr. O’Neil,
I am one of the volunteer Associate Editors at Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). I am currently processing your application for Journal of Peer Production to be included in DOAJ.
Your application states that you do not have article processing charges ( APCs) or article submission charges. However, the link you gave where this information can be found does not mention APCs or submission charges. In order to be included in DOAJ, you must explicitly state that you do not have such charges.
One of the requirements for entry into DOAJ is that your journal website must include an open access statement. The link provided on the application, http://peerproduction.net/, does not have a statement. I would like to suggest that you take a look at some of the journals that are currently in DOAJ. *Film Criticism* has a brief, clear statement about open access that also describes how readers can use the content: http://www.filmcriticismjournal.org/about.html Using such a statement would also fulfill another requirements for inclusion in DOAJ: stating your license or use terms for the reader.
Your application also stated that the author does not hold the copyright without restrictions, and does not retain publishing rights without restrictions. However, I could not find any information about the copyright transfer requirement, or an indication of the rights holder for a published paper. This signals a lack of transparency in the authoring and publishing process. If you send me a link where this information can be found, I can update your DOAJ application.
I look forward to hearing from you soon.
Rhonda Marker
Rhonda J. Marker
Director of Shared User Services
Rutgers University Libraries
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey
p: 848-932-5923 <(848)%20932-5923>
ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7635-816X
-- *Dr Steve Collins* Senior Lecturer in Multimedia Department of Media, Music, Communication & Cultural Studies Macquarie University
P: (02) 9850 2165 W: http://bit.ly/122QivW L: Y3A 191D
-- *Dr Steve Collins* Senior Lecturer in Multimedia Department of Media, Music, Communication & Cultural Studies Macquarie University P: (02) 9850 2165 W: http://bit.ly/122QivW L: Y3A 191D
Hi Steve, all In the black block at the bottom of every webpage it says on the right (in grey so quite hard to read): "Journal of Peer Production - ISSN: 2213-5316 All the contents of this journal are in the public domain." cheers Mathieu ________________________________ From: Steve Collins <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 15:01 To: Mathieu ONeil Cc: Journal list; [email protected] Subject: Re: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Well, in my experience I've not heard of any uni enforcing its rights and restricting authors (I'm sure it's happened to someone, somewhere though :P). Sorry Mathieu, I'm, a little unclear on what you meant by 'now it just says "all pubs in public domain"' - what says that? JoPP? On Thu, Aug 17, 2017 at 2:17 PM, Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Hi Steve, all We had a lot of discussion about (c) in the beginning and adopted I think CC-BY-SA ? but now it just says "all pubs in public domain". I guess we need to stay true to our free software roots somehow, so not sure about the uni/author nexus...? Others? cheers Mathieu ________________________________ From: Steve Collins <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 12:52 To: Mathieu ONeil Cc: Journal list; [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> Subject: Re: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Hi Mathieu What's JoPP's current arrangement with copyrights - is there a current arrangement? I'm guessing that authors don't agree to anything when they submit an article to JoPP. We'll need to implement something for the future - but also need to work on what to do with work that's already been published. To add complexity to the situation it's usual for universities to own the IP in academics' work. I spoke to a colleague who manages an online journal that is registered with DOAJ, and their (c) statement is quite brief but might provide a template? http://shimajournal.org/index.php Publication Details - Shima: The International Journal of ...<http://shimajournal.org/index.php> shimajournal.org<http://shimajournal.org> Shima is a SCOPUS registered peer-refereed academic journal that is published twice a year in open access online form and has been registered with the Directory of ... cheers steve On Thu, Aug 17, 2017 at 11:46 AM, Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Hi all, again To help move things along here are the two places on the journal site where text could be amended. I realise some of you may be enjoying the dolce far niente of the Northern summer, but, well... I've made the required changes to the low-hanging fruit i.e. article processing charges and open access [in bold] below. However for this next requirement I am less certain; where exactly do we stand on author copyright? Steve and Angela, I'm looking at you! 😊 "Your application also stated that the author does not hold the copyright without restrictions, and does not retain publishing rights without restrictions. However, I could not find any information about the copyright transfer requirement, or an indication of the rights holder for a published paper. This signals a lack of transparency in the authoring and publishing process. If you send me a link where this information can be found, I can update your DOAJ application." =-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-= <http://peerproduction.net/about/mission-statement/> Mission Statement The Journal of Peer Production (JoPP) seeks high-quality contributions from researchers and practitioners of peer production. We understand peer production as a mode of commons-based and oriented production in which participation is voluntary and predicated on the self-selection of tasks. Notable examples are the collaborative development of Free Software projects and of the Wikipedia online encyclopedia. Through the analysis of the forms, operations, and contradictions of peer producing communities in contemporary capitalist society, the journal aims to open up new perspectives on the implications of peer production for social change. Topics of interest include, but are not limited to: [etc] CHANGE TO => Mission Statement The Journal of Peer Production (JoPP) seeks high-quality contributions from researchers and practitioners of peer production. We understand peer production as a mode of commons-based and oriented production in which participation is voluntary and predicated on the self-selection of tasks. Notable examples are the collaborative development of Free Software projects and of the Wikipedia online encyclopedia. Through the analysis of the forms, operations, and contradictions of peer producing communities in contemporary capitalist society, the journal aims to open up new perspectives on the implications of peer production for social change. The Journal of Peer Production is an open access academic journal that allows readers to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, and link to the full texts of articles, or use them for any other lawful purpose except where otherwise noted. Topics of interest include, but are not limited to: [etc] =-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-= <http://peerproduction.net/about/submissions/> How to submit to the Journal of Peer Production JoPP will be published twice a year. All scientific contributions will be peer reviewed. If you have a question about the suitability of your contribution to JoPP, please contact the editorial team by posting to the (not publicly archived) editorial team mailing list: jopp [dash] editorial [at] lists [dot] ourproject [dot] org Once papers have been accepted, it is the author’s responsibility to format them in accordance with our specifications. CHANGE TO => How to submit to the Journal of Peer Production No article processing charges (APCs) or article submission charges are required to publish in JoPP. JoPP will be published twice a year. All scientific contributions will be peer reviewed. If you have a question about the suitability of your contribution to JoPP, please contact the editorial team by posting to the (not publicly archived) editorial team mailing list: jopp [dash] editorial [at] lists [dot] ourproject [dot] org Once papers have been accepted, it is the author’s responsibility to format them in accordance with our specifications. =-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-= cheers, Mathieu ________________________________ From: JoPP-Public <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> on behalf of Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 8:44 To: Journal list Subject: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Hi everyone Response from DOAJ FYI. I guess we need to be more explicit in our language. Does anyone have thoughts on the below? cheers Mathieu ________________________________ From: Rhonda Marker <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 8:24 To: Mathieu ONeil Cc: Rhonda Marker Subject: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Dear Dr. O’Neil, I am one of the volunteer Associate Editors at Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). I am currently processing your application for Journal of Peer Production to be included in DOAJ. Your application states that you do not have article processing charges (APCs) or article submission charges. However, the link you gave where this information can be found does not mention APCs or submission charges. In order to be included in DOAJ, you must explicitly state that you do not have such charges. One of the requirements for entry into DOAJ is that your journal website must include an open access statement. The link provided on the application, http://peerproduction.net/, does not have a statement. I would like to suggest that you take a look at some of the journals that are currently in DOAJ. Film Criticism has a brief, clear statement about open access that also describes how readers can use the content: http://www.filmcriticismjournal.org/about.html Using such a statement would also fulfill another requirements for inclusion in DOAJ: stating your license or use terms for the reader. Your application also stated that the author does not hold the copyright without restrictions, and does not retain publishing rights without restrictions. However, I could not find any information about the copyright transfer requirement, or an indication of the rights holder for a published paper. This signals a lack of transparency in the authoring and publishing process. If you send me a link where this information can be found, I can update your DOAJ application. I look forward to hearing from you soon. Rhonda Marker Rhonda J. Marker Director of Shared User Services Rutgers University Libraries Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey p: 848-932-5923<tel:(848)%20932-5923> [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7635-816X -- Dr Steve Collins Senior Lecturer in Multimedia Department of Media, Music, Communication & Cultural Studies Macquarie University P: (02) 9850 2165 W: http://bit.ly/122QivW L: Y3A 191D -- Dr Steve Collins Senior Lecturer in Multimedia Department of Media, Music, Communication & Cultural Studies Macquarie University P: (02) 9850 2165 W: http://bit.ly/122QivW L: Y3A 191D
Hi Steve, all For Shima they say the following (amongst many other things - some good ideas we could use, if we wanted) - is this what you mean? cheers Mathieu The journal is licenced under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License<http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/>. Articles accepted for publication in Shima may be posted in open access repositories and/or on author’s personal research pages upon completion of the journal’s proofing processes in the form supplied to the authors (and identified as forthcoming). [...] Manuscripts which have been published as copyrighted material elsewhere cannot be submitted. In addition, manuscripts under review by the journal should not be resubmitted to copyrighted publications. However, by submitting a manuscript, the author(s) retain the rights to the published material ________________________________ From: JoPP-Public <[email protected]> on behalf of Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 15:38 To: Steve Collins Cc: [email protected]; Journal list Subject: Re: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Hi Steve, all In the black block at the bottom of every webpage it says on the right (in grey so quite hard to read): "Journal of Peer Production - ISSN: 2213-5316 All the contents of this journal are in the public domain." cheers Mathieu ________________________________ From: Steve Collins <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 15:01 To: Mathieu ONeil Cc: Journal list; [email protected] Subject: Re: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Well, in my experience I've not heard of any uni enforcing its rights and restricting authors (I'm sure it's happened to someone, somewhere though :P). Sorry Mathieu, I'm, a little unclear on what you meant by 'now it just says "all pubs in public domain"' - what says that? JoPP? On Thu, Aug 17, 2017 at 2:17 PM, Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Hi Steve, all We had a lot of discussion about (c) in the beginning and adopted I think CC-BY-SA ? but now it just says "all pubs in public domain". I guess we need to stay true to our free software roots somehow, so not sure about the uni/author nexus...? Others? cheers Mathieu ________________________________ From: Steve Collins <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 12:52 To: Mathieu ONeil Cc: Journal list; [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> Subject: Re: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Hi Mathieu What's JoPP's current arrangement with copyrights - is there a current arrangement? I'm guessing that authors don't agree to anything when they submit an article to JoPP. We'll need to implement something for the future - but also need to work on what to do with work that's already been published. To add complexity to the situation it's usual for universities to own the IP in academics' work. I spoke to a colleague who manages an online journal that is registered with DOAJ, and their (c) statement is quite brief but might provide a template? http://shimajournal.org/index.php Publication Details - Shima: The International Journal of ...<http://shimajournal.org/index.php> shimajournal.org<http://shimajournal.org> Shima is a SCOPUS registered peer-refereed academic journal that is published twice a year in open access online form and has been registered with the Directory of ... cheers steve On Thu, Aug 17, 2017 at 11:46 AM, Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Hi all, again To help move things along here are the two places on the journal site where text could be amended. I realise some of you may be enjoying the dolce far niente of the Northern summer, but, well... I've made the required changes to the low-hanging fruit i.e. article processing charges and open access [in bold] below. However for this next requirement I am less certain; where exactly do we stand on author copyright? Steve and Angela, I'm looking at you! 😊 "Your application also stated that the author does not hold the copyright without restrictions, and does not retain publishing rights without restrictions. However, I could not find any information about the copyright transfer requirement, or an indication of the rights holder for a published paper. This signals a lack of transparency in the authoring and publishing process. If you send me a link where this information can be found, I can update your DOAJ application." =-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-= <http://peerproduction.net/about/mission-statement/> Mission Statement The Journal of Peer Production (JoPP) seeks high-quality contributions from researchers and practitioners of peer production. We understand peer production as a mode of commons-based and oriented production in which participation is voluntary and predicated on the self-selection of tasks. Notable examples are the collaborative development of Free Software projects and of the Wikipedia online encyclopedia. Through the analysis of the forms, operations, and contradictions of peer producing communities in contemporary capitalist society, the journal aims to open up new perspectives on the implications of peer production for social change. Topics of interest include, but are not limited to: [etc] CHANGE TO => Mission Statement The Journal of Peer Production (JoPP) seeks high-quality contributions from researchers and practitioners of peer production. We understand peer production as a mode of commons-based and oriented production in which participation is voluntary and predicated on the self-selection of tasks. Notable examples are the collaborative development of Free Software projects and of the Wikipedia online encyclopedia. Through the analysis of the forms, operations, and contradictions of peer producing communities in contemporary capitalist society, the journal aims to open up new perspectives on the implications of peer production for social change. The Journal of Peer Production is an open access academic journal that allows readers to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, and link to the full texts of articles, or use them for any other lawful purpose except where otherwise noted. Topics of interest include, but are not limited to: [etc] =-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-= <http://peerproduction.net/about/submissions/> How to submit to the Journal of Peer Production JoPP will be published twice a year. All scientific contributions will be peer reviewed. If you have a question about the suitability of your contribution to JoPP, please contact the editorial team by posting to the (not publicly archived) editorial team mailing list: jopp [dash] editorial [at] lists [dot] ourproject [dot] org Once papers have been accepted, it is the author’s responsibility to format them in accordance with our specifications. CHANGE TO => How to submit to the Journal of Peer Production No article processing charges (APCs) or article submission charges are required to publish in JoPP. JoPP will be published twice a year. All scientific contributions will be peer reviewed. If you have a question about the suitability of your contribution to JoPP, please contact the editorial team by posting to the (not publicly archived) editorial team mailing list: jopp [dash] editorial [at] lists [dot] ourproject [dot] org Once papers have been accepted, it is the author’s responsibility to format them in accordance with our specifications. =-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=-=-= cheers, Mathieu ________________________________ From: JoPP-Public <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> on behalf of Mathieu ONeil <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 8:44 To: Journal list Subject: [JoPP-Public] Fw: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Hi everyone Response from DOAJ FYI. I guess we need to be more explicit in our language. Does anyone have thoughts on the below? cheers Mathieu ________________________________ From: Rhonda Marker <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 8:24 To: Mathieu ONeil Cc: Rhonda Marker Subject: Your journal application to DOAJ: Journal of Peer Production Dear Dr. O’Neil, I am one of the volunteer Associate Editors at Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). I am currently processing your application for Journal of Peer Production to be included in DOAJ. Your application states that you do not have article processing charges (APCs) or article submission charges. However, the link you gave where this information can be found does not mention APCs or submission charges. In order to be included in DOAJ, you must explicitly state that you do not have such charges. One of the requirements for entry into DOAJ is that your journal website must include an open access statement. The link provided on the application, http://peerproduction.net/, does not have a statement. I would like to suggest that you take a look at some of the journals that are currently in DOAJ. Film Criticism has a brief, clear statement about open access that also describes how readers can use the content: http://www.filmcriticismjournal.org/about.html Using such a statement would also fulfill another requirements for inclusion in DOAJ: stating your license or use terms for the reader. Your application also stated that the author does not hold the copyright without restrictions, and does not retain publishing rights without restrictions. However, I could not find any information about the copyright transfer requirement, or an indication of the rights holder for a published paper. This signals a lack of transparency in the authoring and publishing process. If you send me a link where this information can be found, I can update your DOAJ application. I look forward to hearing from you soon. Rhonda Marker Rhonda J. Marker Director of Shared User Services Rutgers University Libraries Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey p: 848-932-5923<tel:(848)%20932-5923> [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7635-816X -- Dr Steve Collins Senior Lecturer in Multimedia Department of Media, Music, Communication & Cultural Studies Macquarie University P: (02) 9850 2165 W: http://bit.ly/122QivW L: Y3A 191D -- Dr Steve Collins Senior Lecturer in Multimedia Department of Media, Music, Communication & Cultural Studies Macquarie University P: (02) 9850 2165 W: http://bit.ly/122QivW L: Y3A 191D
participants (2)
-
Mathieu ONeil -
Steve Collins